• Analysis
  • 3 min read

Ninety-five per cent of what? Reading the most quoted AI statistic

The claim that 95% of generative AI projects show no return has sat in board decks since August 2025. What the study behind it measured, and what it leaves open.

Olivia9 September 2026 · 3 min read

In August 2025 a report from MIT NANDA called The GenAI Divide produced a line that spread quickly: 95% of generative AI projects deliver no measurable business return, despite $30 billion to $40 billion of enterprise investment.1

It has been repeated widely since, usually as shorthand for the state of AI investment. It is a fair number to quote, as long as its definition goes with it.

What the study did

According to trade press coverage of the report, the authors reviewed more than 300 publicly disclosed AI initiatives, carried out 52 structured interviews and collected 153 survey responses from senior leaders at four conferences, between January and June 2025.1

The yardstick was measurable impact on profit and loss. By that measure, only 5% of integrated AI pilots were extracting millions of dollars in value, and only 5% of custom enterprise AI tools had reached production.1

What it can support

A narrow version of the claim holds up well: in this sample and over this period, very few projects showed a measurable effect on profit and loss. So does the funnel the study describes, in which many organisations evaluate tools, fewer pilot them and fewer still reach production.

The authors identify learning capability as the central barrier, meaning tools that do not keep feedback, adapt to context or get better with use.1 You can check this in your own pilots, and it costs very little to do so.

What it leaves open

Public initiatives and conference surveys are only part of the picture. Private pilots may be under-represented, and so may projects whose value is real but hard to pin to one line of the P&L. Six months of fieldwork can also miss projects that pay back in their second year.

Other studies ask different questions, so their answers fall in a different range. McKinsey’s 2026 survey found 37% of respondents attributing at least some EBIT impact to AI.2 IBM’s 2025 CEO study reported that 25% of AI initiatives had delivered the expected ROI.3 These can’t be averaged with MIT’s figure, because each counts something different.

Until you know how a study defined success, its failure rate doesn’t tell you much.

Before you quote it

Three details should travel with the number. First, the measure of success, since revenue, cost, EBIT, adoption and expected ROI each give a different answer. Then the period, because a twelve-month window and a thirty-six-month window describe different projects. And finally the sample: public cases, surveyed executives and a random sample of firms each lean in their own direction.

A board paper can quote 95% from MIT and 37% from McKinsey on the same page, provided both carry those details, so that nobody reads them as contradicting each other.

Notes

The MIT NANDA report is cited through the trade press article named below.

  1. MIT Report Finds Most AI Business Investments Fail, Reveals "GenAI Divide" (coverage of MIT NANDA, The GenAI Divide: State of AI in Business 2025)Virtualization Review, 19 August 2025
  2. The state of AI in 2026: On the road to ROIMcKinsey & Company, 25 August 2026
  3. IBM Study: CEOs Double Down on AI While Navigating Enterprise HurdlesIBM, 6 May 2025

BIAAS 2027, Amsterdam

Hear it first-hand from the people doing the work

Two days of keynotes, panels and 1-on-1 meetings with senior data, analytics and AI leaders, on 23-24 March 2027.